Schulich Clinical Skills · History taking · FoM → T2C

Presenting a case

A case is presented in the same order the history was taken. Each part is below with what to say and the slip to avoid, then the summary, differential and plan, and the written Problem-Oriented Clinical Record. Built from the Clinical Skills objectives and the course interviewing template; anything taught in the T2C Surgery and Consolidation sessions is tagged later.

Pick a region below to jump to it.

Identification and chief complaint → HPI (FIFE) → Past history, medications → Habits and social → Family → Review of systems → Physical exam → One-line summary → Problem list and differential → Plan

Clear and concise, in the order of the interviewing template: say what matters for this problem, the findings that are present and the ones that are absent.

General approach

Every presentation

The general approach

  • Say it first (TOSCE, Teaching Objective Structured Clinical Exam): "[Name] is a [age]-year-old [occupation] who presents with [chief complaint] for [how long]."
  • Who you present to: present the case to peers and faculty (your group and group leader) in a clear, concise manner, using the framework provided; in Surgery, to the consultant
  • Keep the order: the order of the interviewing template, every time, so the listener knows where you are
  • Tell a story: the HPI in time order, from the first symptom to today
  • Be selective: give the pertinent positives and negatives for the chief complaint; "non-contributory" covers the rest extra
  • End with your thinking: summary → what you think is going on → what you would do next
  • Then ask for feedback: reflect on the encounter and use feedback from peers, standardized patients (SPs) and group leaders to improve; give constructive feedback on your peers' encounters

The oral presentation

FoM · Introduction to Interviewing · 9 parts

Who and why

Identification and chief complaint

Who the patient is and why they came

What to say
  1. "Ms. A is a 54-year-old teacher who presents with three days of chest pain."
Common slip

Leaving out how long the problem has gone on

History of presenting illness

The story of the main problem

What to say
  1. "It began suddenly while she was walking. It is a pressure-like pain in the centre of the chest…": site, onset, character, radiation, associated symptoms, timeline, what makes it worse or better, severity
Common slip

Jumping around in time · forgetting what the patient has already tried

The patient's illness experience (FIFE)

The person, not just the disease

What to say
  1. "She is frightened because her father had a heart attack at her age, and she hopes to find out whether this is her heart."
Common slip

Dropping FIFE from the presentation

The background

Past medical history

Conditions that change the picture

What to say
  1. Chronic illnesses, hospitalizations, surgeries, mental health history, vaccines and screening
Common slip

Listing every childhood illness instead of what is relevant

Medications and allergies

Safety

What to say
  1. Each medication with dose and frequency · adherence · allergies with the reaction
Common slip

Saying "on a blood pressure pill" with no name or dose · "allergic to penicillin" with no reaction

Habits and social history

Risk factors and context

What to say
  1. Smoking (pack-years), alcohol, drugs · work, living situation, supports · ADLs and IADLs (activities of daily living and instrumental activities of daily living) when function matters
Common slip

Skipping social history, or giving it without the impact on the illness

Family history

Inherited risk

What to say
  1. Conditions in parents, siblings and children relevant to the complaint, with ages
Common slip

"Family history negative" without saying for what

What you found

Review of systems

Anything else found

What to say
  1. Only the positives and the negatives that matter for this complaint
Common slip

Reading the whole review of systems aloud

Physical exam

The findings

What to say
  1. General appearance and vital signs first (section 3), then the system examined
Common slip

Interpreting ("looks like heart failure") instead of describing what you found

Reporting the physical exam

FoM · Primary Physical Exam Skills

How to open it

What to say

  • General inspection, as one sentence: "[Name] is a [age]-year-old [woman/man], well-groomed, well-oriented. Calm affect. Stable mood. No cyanosis, plethora, pallor, jaundice, or skin signs. No involuntary movements or abnormal odours."
  • Vital signs, with their quality: "Heart rate is [X], regular rhythm, normal amplitude and contour; respiratory rate is [X]; blood pressure is [X] (right and left arms); temperature is [X]."
  • When findings are abnormal, describe what you see: distress, how many words they can say per breath, position, muscle use, which arm the blood pressure was taken in
  • Then the system you examined, in its usual order (inspection, palpation, percussion, auscultation, or look, feel, move)

Summary, differential and plan

T2C · Surgery, Consolidation

How to open it

What to say

  • One-line summary: age, key background, the main problem and the key findings from history and exam
  • Differential diagnosis: formulate and prioritize a differential diagnosis from the history and physical exam, most urgent conditions first
    • run the VITAMIN C&D checklist so nothing is missed: Vascular · Infection/inflammation · Trauma · Autoimmune, acquired, allergic · Metabolic, mental health · Iatrogenic (caused by treatment) · Neoplasm · Congenital, cyst · Degenerative
  • Plan: a preliminary diagnostic and therapeutic plan: what tests, what treatment, what follow-up
    • research the necessary investigations for the most likely diagnoses and develop a management plan, including evidence-based lifestyle factors: nutrition, stress management, restorative sleep and physical activity
    • appreciate the roles of other health care professionals in the patient's care
  • Common ground: establish common ground in the doctor–patient encounter: the plan you present is the one the patient agreed to, and you say what they expect

The written record

T2C · Consolidation · 5 parts

How to open it

What to say

  • Document the history, physical exam and problem list in a Problem-Oriented Clinical Record, and use it to document a complete clinical encounter
  • Create the written record of the encounter in an organized, concise manner
  • To pass Consolidation: one observed history and physical exam and two written patient record assessments, submitted by the due date

The database

History

The full database

What to say
  1. Every part of the interviewing template, in order, in full sentences or clear notes
Common slip

Writing it as a transcript of the conversation instead of under the template's headings

Physical exam (write-up)

Findings

What to say
  1. General appearance, vital signs, then each system examined
Common slip

Leaving out normal findings that matter for the complaint

Your reasoning

Problem list

Every active issue

What to say
  1. Each problem on its own line: the chief complaint first, then the others found (e.g. high blood pressure, smoking, food insecurity)
Common slip

Listing only the chief complaint

Assessment and plan, per problem

Your reasoning

What to say
  1. For each problem: prioritized differential, then investigations, treatment and follow-up, including lifestyle advice
Common slip

One plan for everything instead of a plan for each problem extra

Learning issues

What you need to read

What to say
  1. Personal learning issues and goals raised by this patient
Common slip

Leaving it blank

A surgical patient

T2C · Surgery

How to open it

What to say

  • Conduct a focused history and physical exam of a patient with a potential surgical condition, using surgical principles
  • Perform at least one surgical history and physical and synthesize it into a diagnosis and plan
  • Summarize one surgical history and physical for presentation to the consultant, using the Problem-Oriented Medical Record as the framework
  • Create a preliminary differential diagnosis, and a diagnostic and therapeutic plan
  • Explain how the surgical process affects the patient (patient-centred care): use FIFE: their feelings about an operation, what they think will be done, how recovery will affect work and home, and what they expect afterwards
  • For an urgent surgical problem, the history adds SAMPLE:
    • Signs and symptoms · Allergies · Medications · Past medical history, including past surgeries and any reactions to anaesthesia · Last meal · Events leading up to the problem

After the presentation

T2C · Consolidation

How to open it

What to say

  • Identify personal learning issues and goals from the patient encounter
  • Build on self-reflection and faculty feedback to keep improving communication, clinical skills and clinical reasoning
Video credits

There are no videos or pictures on this page: a history is a conversation, so the skill is in what you say and what you listen for. Practise the questions out loud.