Schulich Clinical Skills · History taking · PoM 2

The psychiatric interview

The mental status exam is gathered the whole way through, not as a separate step. Each part of the interview is below: what to say to open it, then what to ask or assess, grouped by what you are working out, and what to listen for. Built from the PoM 2 psychiatry lectures and the CS2 Psychiatry objectives. Safety is asked about in every psychiatric interview.

Pick a region below to jump to it.

Identification → Presenting illness → Psychiatric screen → Past psychiatric history → Medical history and medications → Family → Personal and social → Wind down, formulation, plan

Two components, held in balance: content (information, symptoms) and process (rapport, empathy). The mental status exam is gathered the whole way through.

General approach

Every psychiatric interview

The general approach

  • Say it first (TOSCE, Teaching Objective Structured Clinical Exam): "Some of the questions I'll ask are personal. I ask them of everyone I see, and you can tell me if you'd rather not answer something."
  • Two components, held in balance
    • Content: information and symptoms, which build the diagnostic hypothesis
    • Process: rapport and empathy, the relationship that lets the patient trust you with sensitive information
  • Interview skills: use greeting, open-ended questions, effective listening, empathic comments, paraphrasing, summarizing and reassurance
    • funnel strategy: start open ("What brought you to the hospital today?"), then specific ("How is your anxiety interfering with your life?"), then closed, verifying questions ("Do you isolate yourself when depressed?")
    • empathic comment: "That sounds frightening." · paraphrase: "So the voices started after you stopped the medication?" · summarize at each change of section
  • Therapeutic alliance: build rapport while keeping appropriate boundaries (friendly, not a friend)
  • Transference and countertransference: recognize them and the effect they have on the patient-doctor relationship
    • transference: the patient unconsciously redirects feelings about someone from their past onto you (e.g. treats you like a dismissive parent)
    • countertransference: your own unconscious reaction to the patient (e.g. dreading a patient, or giving one who reminds you of a friend extra time)
  • Your own biases: recognize personal biases and keep them from interfering with the patient's best interests; afterwards, reflect on the interview for bias and transference/countertransference
  • Adjust to the situation: a focused, structured interview: adjust the history and MSE to the patient's complaint and the setting (an emergency needs safety first; a clinic follow-up needs the course of illness)

Identification and the presenting illness

PoM 2 · Psychiatry · 5 areas to ask about

How to open it

What to say

  • Identifying data: name · age · gender (ask pronouns if not obvious) · marital and parental status (who is caring for the children now?) · occupation and finances · cultural background
  • Chief complaint in the patient's own words, then the history of presenting illness (HPI) with your hypotheses in mind

Telling the story

The problem, openly

The patient's story

Ask or assess
  1. "What difficulties are you experiencing today?"
Listen for

The main symptom group (mood, anxiety, psychosis, substances) to aim the rest of the interview

A reference point

Where "present" begins

Ask or assess
  1. "When were you last well? When were you content with how you were functioning?"
Listen for

A date or event: separates this episode from the past psychiatric history

What set it off, what it cost

Precipitants

What set it off

Ask or assess
  1. "Did anything change before this started?"
Listen for

Relationship difficulties · stopping treatment or a medication change · substance use · a medical illness or new medical drug

Impact

Severity

Ask or assess
  1. "How is this affecting your work, home and relationships?"
Listen for

Loss of function (stopped working, not leaving the house, not eating)

Coping and others

Supports, risk to others

Ask or assess
  1. "How have you been coping? How is this affecting the people around you?"
Listen for

Healthy coping vs using alcohol or drugs to cope

The psychiatric screen

PoM 2 · Psychiatry · 9 areas to ask about

How to open it

What to say

  • Screen every major group, even when the complaint points to one: a depressed patient may also be manic, anxious or drinking. This is how you recognize and screen for the major disorders: anxiety, mood, substance use, personality, psychotic and cognitive.

Mood and anxiety

Depression

A major depressive episode

Ask or assess
  1. "Have you been feeling down or depressed, or lost interest in things, most of the day, nearly every day, for 2 weeks or more?"
Listen for

Low mood or loss of interest for 2 weeks or more · then SIGECAPS: Sleep, Interest, Guilt, Energy, Concentration, Appetite, Psychomotor change, Suicide

Mania or hypomania

Bipolar disorder

Ask or assess
  1. "Have you ever had a time when you felt so 'up' or full of energy that you got into trouble, or others said you weren't yourself?"
Listen for

Elevated or irritable mood (not while intoxicated) · less need for sleep · fast, pressured speech · racing thoughts · grandiosity · risky behaviour · ⚠ always ask about mania in anyone depressed · DIGFAST (3 or more, 4 if only irritable): Distractibility · Indiscretion (spending, sex) · Grandiosity · Flight of ideas · Activity up or agitation · Sleep need down · Talkative (pressured)

Anxiety

Generalized anxiety, panic, phobias, trauma

Ask or assess
  1. "Do you worry a lot about everyday things? Have you had sudden rushes of fear with a racing heart?"
Listen for

Hard-to-control worry · panic attacks peaking within minutes · avoidance · nightmares or flashbacks after a trauma · generalized anxiety: worry most days for 6 months or more, plus 3 of 6: restless (keyed up) · easily tired · poor concentration (mind going blank) · irritable · muscle tension · poor sleep (BE SKIM)

Trauma

Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD)

Ask or assess
  1. "Has something very frightening or upsetting happened to you? Do you have frightening dreams about it, or flashbacks where it feels like it's happening again? Do you avoid places or thoughts that remind you of it?"
Listen for

Re-experiencing (nightmares, flashbacks) · avoidance · numbing, can't enjoy things · on edge · a month or more (TRAUMA: Traumatic event · Re-experiencing · Avoidance · Unable to function · Month or more · Arousal)

Obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD)

Obsessions, compulsions

Ask or assess
  1. "Do you have upsetting thoughts or urges that keep coming back? Do you feel driven to wash, check or count?"
Listen for

Intrusive, unwanted thoughts and repeated acts that relieve the anxiety

Reality, eating and substances

Psychosis

Hallucinations, delusions

Ask or assess
  1. "Have you heard things other people couldn't hear, such as voices? Have you felt people were watching you or plotting against you?"
Listen for

Voices, visions · being followed, mind read, special messages · only when sad or high? (mood disorder with psychotic features)

Eating disorder

Anorexia, bulimia

Ask or assess
  1. "Are you preoccupied with your weight, or with food?"
Listen for

Restricting, bingeing, purging, fear of weight gain

Substance use

Substance use disorder

Ask or assess
  1. "How much alcohol do you drink in a week? Do you use cannabis or other drugs?"
Listen for

Use despite harm · tolerance · withdrawal · failed attempts to cut down · time spent getting or using · alcohol screens: AUDIT (10 items) is the better screen; CAGE (felt you should Cut down · Annoyed by criticism · Guilty · Eye-opener) is the quick one

Risk

Safety

Suicide, self-harm, violence

Ask or assess
  1. "Have you had thoughts of ending your life, or of hurting someone else?"
Listen for

Any yes → full risk assessment (section 4)

Pearls

Remember

  • Tentative diagnosis: apply the DSM-5 (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 5th edition) criteria to make a tentative diagnosis of anxiety, depression, psychosis, substance use, personality and cognitive disorders. The screen tells you which criteria set to check.
  • Normal sadness (e.g. bereavement) vs a mood disorder: grief comes in waves tied to reminders of the loss, with self-esteem preserved; a depressive episode is pervasive, with worthlessness, guilt and loss of function.
  • Situational stress vs an anxiety disorder vs drugs or a medical condition: is the worry in proportion to a real stressor, and does it settle? Ask about caffeine, stimulants, alcohol or benzodiazepine withdrawal, and medical causes (e.g. thyroid).
  • Primary psychotic disorder vs other causes of psychosis: think substance intoxication or withdrawal and medical conditions (e.g. delirium) when onset is sudden, the patient is older, or hallucinations are visual.
  • Long-enduring patterns vs short-lived episodes: a personality disorder is a pattern present since adolescence or early adulthood, across situations; mood and psychotic disorders come in episodes with a "last well" date.

Safety: suicide and homicide

PoM 2 · Psychiatry · 9 areas to ask about

How to open it

What to say

  • Ask directly and calmly. Be honest about why you ask, take the time to listen, validate the person's story and their decision to seek help, and stay non-judgmental.
  • If an answer doesn't fit the question, reframe the question: patients can misunderstand, or avoid.
  • Self-injury is not the same as suicidal ideation: explore what it does for the person. It is easily missed while looking for the bigger safety concerns.

Thoughts of dying

Ideation

Thoughts of death or suicide

Ask or assess
  1. "Sometimes when people feel this low, they think about dying or ending their life. Has that happened to you?"
Listen for

Passive (no effort to think about it or plan) vs ⚠ active (thinking it through, planning, moving to act)

How it feels to them

Ego-syntonic vs ego-dystonic

Ask or assess
  1. "How do you feel about having these thoughts?"
Listen for

Dystonic: distressing, unwanted · ⚠ syntonic: fits their current values, not distressing (a red flag)

Plan

How far it has gone

Ask or assess
  1. "Have you thought about how you would do it? When, and where?"
Listen for

⚠ A specific plan: get the details (method, timing, place); don't assume

Access to means

Can they act on it

Ask or assess
  1. "Do you have access to pills, or to a firearm?"
Listen for

⚠ Seeking or having the means (stockpiled pills, a gun at home)

Intent

Will they act

Ask or assess
  1. "Do you think you would act on these thoughts?"
Listen for

⚠ Stated intent, or preparations (writing a note, giving things away)

Past and present risk

Past attempts

The strongest history clue

Ask or assess
  1. "Have you ever tried to end your life? What happened?"
Listen for

Number, method and intent of each · what led up to it (the chain of events) · what saved them and how they felt about surviving · interrupted or aborted attempts

Warning signs

Imminent risk

Ask or assess
  1. "How hopeful do you feel about the future?"
Listen for

IS PATH WARM: Ideation · Substance use · Purposelessness · Anger · Trapped · ⚠ Hopelessness · Withdrawal (from people) · Anxiety · Recklessness · Mood changes

Protective factors

Reasons for living

Ask or assess
  1. "What has kept you going? What keeps you safe?"
Listen for

Strong relationships (family, community, culture, religion), belonging, future goals, willingness to accept help

Risk to others

Homicidal thoughts

Risk to others

Ask or assess
  1. "Have you had thoughts of hurting anyone else? Who?"
Listen for

Same approach as suicide: ideation, plan, means, intent, and who

Pearls

Remember

  • ⚠ Red flags: active threats · talking about wanting to die · seeking access to means · hopelessness · unexpected talk or writing about death.
  • Risk is weighed from risk factors + warning signs + protective factors, and it is "not psychological math". In a severe-risk situation, protective factors may count for little.
  • ⚠ Decide whether the patient needs emergency care because of withdrawal symptoms, complications, violence, suicide or abuse, and act: stay with the patient, tell your supervisor, keep the setting safe.
    • inpatient vs outpatient depends on the acuity and severity of the risk and the safety net at home
    • in Ontario, any physician can complete a Form 1 (Application for Psychiatric Assessment) for an involuntary assessment when a mental disorder makes the person a danger to self or others
    • safety (crisis) plan: steps for a crisis · coping plan: strategies to stop stress escalating · ⚠ a "no-suicide contract" is not acceptable management
  • Collateral (family, family doctor) can confirm or challenge what you heard; privacy can be breached only when safety requires it, with care.

Past psychiatric history

PoM 2 · Psychiatry

How to open it

What to say

  • Goals: the longitudinal course of the illness · its severity · the predisposing, precipitating and protective factors
  • The illness: age of onset · first symptoms and triggers · functioning before and after · number and length of hospitalizations
  • Impact: "How is your life different because of the illness?" · "How do you cope?" · "What opportunities were lost?"
  • Treatments
    • biological: medications (names, doses, how long) · electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) · repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) · bright light therapy (BLT)
    • psychosocial: which psychotherapy, and what strategies were learned
    • "Has anything made a difference?"
  • Add to the MSE: insight (does the patient appreciate their symptoms and what drives them?) and judgement (decisions that led to action: leaving an abusive relationship, starting therapy, getting sober)

Medical, medications, family

PoM 2 · Psychiatry · 5 areas to ask about

How to open it

What to say

  • Medical history: ask for every patient, then target the medical problems each disorder brings

Medical problems that come with it

Mood disorders

Weight change

Ask or assess
  1. "Has your weight changed?"
Listen for

Weight loss (melancholic depression) · weight gain from carbohydrate craving (seasonal depression)

Schizophrenia, bipolar disorder

Metabolic disease

Ask or assess
  1. "Have you been told you have diabetes or high cholesterol?"
Listen for

Diabetes · dyslipidemia

Substance use: medical complications

Complications of use

Ask or assess
  1. "Have you ever injected drugs? Been tested for HIV or hepatitis?"
Listen for

Skin lesions (crystal methamphetamine) · abscesses, HIV, hepatitis B and C (injection) · alcoholic pancreatitis

OCD

Skin damage

Ask or assess
  1. "Do your hands get sore from washing?"
Listen for

Excoriation (picking), maceration from handwashing

Family

Family history

Inherited and environmental risk

Ask or assess
  1. "Has anyone in your biological family had mental health problems, problems with alcohol or drugs, or attempted suicide?"
Listen for

Mental illness · substance use · eccentric behaviour · suicide attempts or deaths · estrangement

Pearls

Remember

  • Medications and allergies, including over-the-counter and herbal remedies. A recent medication change can be the precipitant.
  • Non-biological relatives still matter: an alcoholic step-parent shapes the environment, not the genes.

Personal and social history

PoM 2 · Psychiatry · 8 areas to ask about

How to open it

What to say

  • Go chronologically, from childhood, once rapport exists, keeping your hypothesis in mind and showing genuine interest.

Growing up

Development

Early environment

Ask or assess
  1. "What was home like growing up? Who raised you?"
Listen for

Pregnancy and birth problems (briefly) · two or single parent · attachment (closeness, instability) · clear, consistent family rules

Childhood adversity

Abuse, neglect

Ask or assess
  1. "Were your needs met? Did you ever see violence at home? Were you ever touched in a way that made you uncomfortable?"
Listen for

Violence, punishment out of proportion, sexual abuse

School

Learning, bullying

Ask or assess
  1. "How did you do in school? Any difficult experiences, like being bullied?"
Listen for

Special classes, repeated grades, bullying

Personality

Lifelong traits

Ask or assess
  1. "What were you like as a child: outgoing, or shy and quiet?"
Listen for

Interests, friendships, enduring patterns

Adult life

Relationships and supports

Social support

Ask or assess
  1. "Are you in a relationship now? Who can you count on?"
Listen for

Pattern across relationships · current support (relatives, friends, community)

Sexual history

Sexual health

Ask or assess
  1. "Are you attracted to men, women, or both? What protection do you use?"
Listen for

Orientation, safer sex, past STIs (sexually transmitted infections), sexual difficulties

Legal history

Legal problems

Ask or assess
  1. "Have you ever been charged with an offence, or been on probation?"
Listen for

Charges, convictions, probation or parole, driving offences, upcoming court dates

Occupation

Function over time

Ask or assess
  1. "What is your main line of work? What's the longest you've stayed in a job?"
Listen for

Education, job history, current work situation

Mental status exam

PoM 2 · Psychiatry · 15 areas to ask about

How to open it

What to say

  • Mostly an objective description gathered by observation during the interview (not a separate part), then reported as its own heading in the case presentation. Components: ABC STAMP LICKER.
  • Identify and report common MSE findings in the major disorders (last column).

How they look and act

Appearance

Identifying features

Ask or assess
  1. Watch from the first moment
Listen for

Dress wrong for the weather or setting, poor grooming or hygiene (depression, psychosis) · flamboyant (mania)

Behaviour

Activity, eye contact, movements

Ask or assess
  1. Observe throughout
Listen for

Slowed (depression) · restless, agitated (mania, anxiety, withdrawal) · tremor, stereotypies (purposeless repeated acts), posturing

Cooperation

Willingness to engage

Ask or assess
  1. How the interview goes
Listen for

Argumentative, evasive, guarded (paranoia) · accessibility: is the patient willing and able to share?

How they talk and think

Speech

The "pulse" of the MSE

Ask or assess
  1. Listen: rate, rhythm, tone, volume, latency (delay before answering)
Listen for

Pressured (a need to speak: mania) · poverty of speech (few words) · poverty of content (many words, little information) · mutism, dysarthria

Thought form

How thoughts flow

Ask or assess
  1. From the speech
Listen for

Circumstantial (detours, gets there) · tangential (never gets there) · flight of ideas (fast jumps: mania) · derailing (abrupt unconnected change) · loosening of associations (no logical link: psychosis)

Thought content

What the patient thinks about

Ask or assess
  1. Ask about worries and beliefs
Listen for

Delusions (fixed false beliefs out of keeping with the patient's culture: persecutory, grandiose, reference, nihilistic, jealousy, erotomanic) · overvalued ideas · obsessions, phobias

How they feel

Affect

Emotion shown in the moment (objective)

Ask or assess
  1. Watch the face and tone
Listen for

Restricted (to one feeling, e.g. sad) · flat (schizophrenia) · inappropriate to the content · incongruent with the stated mood

Mood

The patient's state over time (subjective)

Ask or assess
  1. "How would you describe your mood lately?", in their words
Listen for

Depressed · euphoric · irritable · anxious

What they perceive

Perception

Hallucinations, illusions

Ask or assess
  1. "Do you ever hear or see things others don't?"
Listen for

Hallucination (perception with no stimulus; auditory commonest: command, running commentary) · illusion (a real stimulus misperceived) · pseudohallucination (experienced "in the mind's eye or ear")

Level of consciousness

Alertness

Ask or assess
  1. Observe
Listen for

Drowsy, fluctuating (delirium, intoxication)

Judging the patient

Insight and judgement

Not the same thing

Ask or assess
  1. "What do you think is going on? What would help?"
Listen for

Poor insight: doesn't see the illness or the need for treatment · poor judgement: can't weigh consequences (focus on illness-related choices)

Cognition

Orientation, attention, memory, executive function

Ask or assess
  1. Person, place, date; months backwards; recall; MoCA if concerned (section 9)
Listen for

Disoriented, inattentive (delirium) · memory loss (dementia)

Knowledge and intelligence

What they know, and what they do with it

Ask or assess
  1. From vocabulary and answers
Listen for

Below what education predicts

Endings: safety

Suicidal and homicidal thoughts

Ask or assess
  1. Always ask (section 4)
Listen for

Passive vs active, ego-syntonic, plan, intent

Reliability

Can you trust the history?

Ask or assess
  1. Consistent with other data and within the interview?
Listen for

Inconsistencies, gaps · get collateral

Pearls

Remember

  • Mood is the climate, affect is the weather. Report mood in the patient's own words.
  • Hallucinations are not always illness: on falling asleep or waking (hypnagogic, hypnopompic), or with poor vision (Charles Bonnet syndrome).
  • Phenomenology: describe how the patient experiences a symptom, not just its name. "Auditory hallucinations" doesn't tell you what the voices are like: ask the volume, whose voice, what they say, whether the patient talks back.

Cognitive screen (MoCA)

PoM 2 · Psychiatry · 8 areas to ask about

How to open it

What to say

  • Demonstrate skill in using the MoCA: about 10 minutes, out of 30; below 26 suggests cognitive impairment. It catches mild cognitive impairment better than the Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE).
  • Read the instructions exactly as written and don't give hints. Make sure glasses and hearing aids are on.

Planning and abstraction

Visuospatial and executive

Planning, drawing

Ask or assess
  1. Trail making (1-A-2-B…) · copy the cube · draw a clock (contour, numbers, hands)
Listen for

Errors (1 + 1 + 3 points)

Abstraction

Abstract thinking

Ask or assess
  1. "How are a train and a bicycle alike?"
Listen for

Concrete answers (2 points)

Language and place

Naming

Language

Ask or assess
  1. Name 3 animals (lion, rhinoceros, camel)
Listen for

Cannot name them (3 points)

Language

Repetition, fluency

Ask or assess
  1. Repeat 2 sentences · words starting with one letter in 1 minute
Listen for

Fewer than 11 words (2 + 1 points)

Orientation

Time and place

Ask or assess
  1. Date, month, year, day, place, city
Listen for

Errors (6 points)

Memory and attention

Memory: learning

Registration

Ask or assess
  1. Read 5 words, twice
Listen for

No points yet: recalled later

Attention

Concentration

Ask or assess
  1. Digits forward and backward · tap at each letter A · serial 7s from 100
Listen for

Errors (2 + 1 + 3 points)

Delayed recall

Short-term memory

Ask or assess
  1. The 5 words, with no cues
Listen for

Missed words (5 points)

Pearls

Remember

  • The score is influenced by age and education: the MoCA instructions add 1 point for 12 years of education or less extra.
  • ⚠ Don't use the MoCA in delirium (acute, fluctuating confusion).

Winding down and plan

PoM 2 · Psychiatry

How to open it

What to say

  • Winding down: don't finish on a sensitive topic · thank the patient · acknowledge their commitment · ask if anything was missed · ask FIFE: the patient's Feelings, Ideas, Function and Expectations about the problem · ask how they feel now · discuss the plan
  • Formulation: the biological, psychological and social factors that predisposed the patient, and those that protected them
  • Plan: a biopsychosocial initial treatment plan adapted to the patient
    • most urgent next steps · how to deal with safety issues · inpatient or outpatient
    • biological (e.g. medication) · psychological supports and therapy · social (housing, work, supports)
  • Explain it: communicate the working diagnosis and plan in clear, plain language the patient understands; find common ground when you disagree
  • Refer: help patients access the system for physical, psychological, social and economic rehabilitation or long-term care (e.g. community mental health, addiction services, social work)
  • Limits: seek help or consultation when needed, and accept you can't be "all things to all people": defer some requests, kindly.
  • Present the case: summarize the clinical, biological and psychosocial information to the group leader and peers, clearly and concisely: identification, chief complaint, HPI, pertinent screen positives and negatives, past history, MSE, risk assessment, tentative diagnosis, plan.
Video credits

There are no videos or pictures on this page: a history is a conversation, so the skill is in what you say and what you listen for. Practise the questions out loud.